Comparative Analysis of John Rawls Justice as Fairness and Irving Essay - 15

Comparative Analysis of John Rawls Justice as Fairness and Irving Kristols A Capitalist design of Justice - Essay ExampleThe flaw with this argument is that an individual gets economically rewarded for those attributes of his personality that he did non cultivate, evolve or learn of his own industry and enterprise. In other words, talents in rendering music, numeric ability and good looks, etc are to a large extent genetically determined. So what we see present is a subtle form of Eugenics. There are also shades of Social Darwinism attached to Kristols hypothesis, wherein the capitalist system will eliminate those individuals who are unable to contribute to the economy. It is also impetuous of Kristol to offer that luck is a valid determinant of human dignity. To imply that the indignation suffered by those living in absolute poverty is a matter of bad fortune while the luxuries enjoyed by the rich nonage are attributable to an element of good luck is too simplistic an argument to make. In devising a comparison between social referee and capitalism Kristol mentions how capitalism is neither egalitarian nor authoritarian. unmatched gets an impression that there is no virtue in aspiring for an egalitarian society and that authoritarianism is inherently defective. Both the conceptions are false. Secondly, authoritarianism is not a decadent concept as the author would render us believe. There are objections to this line of argument. First of all, isnt it a universal principle of justice and decency that no section of humanity should be living in absolute poverty?